ALBERT EINSTEIN'S ZIONISM
The Humanitarian Impulse Behind the Movement to Resurrect the Jewish Homeland
as seen through the eyes of its most exceptional advocate


A year-by-year account of Einstein's take on ideas and events as they shaped the Zionist struggle
(THIS WORK IS UNDER CONSTRUCTION. EDITORIAL REVIEW, COPYEDITING, FULL REFERENCING, PERMISSIONS AND CREDITING IS IN PROGRESS)

An Internet Project By

Daniel S Cutler

 

© 2005

All Einstein writings © Estate of Albert Einstein
Photos, images © as noted. More on ©  here.
Section 2 of  8
 

Before Zionism
1879-1899
1900-1909
1910-1919
1920-1929
1930-1939
1940-1949
 
Childhood - Schooling, Marriage, Fatherhood
Two New Words: "Anti-Semitism" and "Pogrom"
Einstein's Life, as the Zionist Movement Takes Shape

1879
GERMAN EMPIRE

14 March

A son is born to Herman and Pauline Einstein in Ulm, Wurttembe. They name him Albert.
Thoroughly modern Herman and Pauline are proud that they do not observe Jewish religious rites at home. Religious matters are of no interest to them. (Pais, Abraham, Subtle is the Lord: The Science and the Life of Albert Einstein, Oxford University Press 1982. pg. 36)

Einstein's Parents
Hermann and Pauline Einstein (nee Koch)
Married in a small town synagogue on
August 8, 1876. Three years later they name their first son Albert, after his grandfather Abraham. The birth certificate noted that both mother and father were of the "Israelitic faith".

.

.

.

.

.

.

Earliest photo of Einstein
Born the same year as Einstein:
The word "Anti-Semitism"

Coined by German politician Wilhelm Marr in his 1879 pamphlet The War Between Jewishness and Germaness. Marr intended his new word to update the current phrase Judenhass -- "Jew-hatred". The older term suggests a medieval, theological perspective. Marr wished to substitute a more modern, "scientific" term. No longer were Jews to be excluded from German society because they rejected Christ. In the new thinking Jews could never be assimilated because they were genetically incompatible with German people. (The pseudoscientific, imprecise term always referred only to Jews. It took no account of Arabs or other Semitic language peoples).

1880
Einstein family moves to Munich.
Hermann and his younger brother Jackob start a gas and water installation business. A few years later they sell and install electric generators. Uncle
Jacob will introduce Albert to pleasure of solving math problems.
Hermann and Paula have daughter.
Albert's new sister is named Maria, a Christian name unthinkable for a Jewish girl prior to Emancipation. She is known to family as Maja.

With younger sister Maja
 
RUSSIAN EMPIRE:
Czar Alexander II assassinated (on 8th try) by terrorist faction of utopian Narodnaya Volya (The People's Will).
Rumor that Jews were behind the killing sparks government-authorized revenge against the Jews.

Russian Czar Alexander II
"The Liberator Czar" freed the serfs (in 1861, two years before Lincoln freed the slaves). In other reforms he liberalized the press laws, opened formerly secret trials to public scrutiny, allowed Jews into Russia's cities, and opened to them the opportunity to study in Russian universities. His advisors conclude Jewish capitalists are behind the reforms.

He is murdered by terrorists - disaffected upper class youths - who fear his reforms might suffice the masses and divert them from true revolution.

Russian Czar Alexander III
Having watched his father bleed to death after the terrorist bomb blew off his legs, Alexander III becomes a fierce reactionary. He reverses every one of his father's reforms within days and gives unlimited new powers to police and to his internal spy agency.  During his rule terrorism and repression thrive on each other.

Russian policy makers believe Jews are behind both his father's reforms and his assassination. His "Temporary Laws" against Jews stay in effect for 30 years.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

Another New Word: "Pogrom"

from Russian  погром "a wreaking of havoc"
Massive violence targeting Jews, often with collusion of authorities. The word as come to be used for mob violence that singles out any specific ethnic group.

Rampaging mob during 1881 pogrom depicted in newspaper illustration

Jewish street destroyed in pogrom in 1881

Pogrom violence against Jews in 166 towns
Thousands of Jewish homes destroyed, many families reduced to extremes of poverty; women sexually assaulted, and large numbers of men, women, and children killed or injured in 166 Russian towns. The most serious pogrom is in Kiev. Jews are expelled from Moscow.

1882
RUSSIAN EMPIRE:

Czar Alexander III introduces anti-Semitic "May Laws"
Designed to cause "one-third of the Jews to emigrate, one-third to accept baptism, and one-third to starve". Jews are banned from all rural areas and towns of less than ten thousand people. Strict quotas are placed on the number of Jews allowed into secondary and higher education and into many professions. Called "Temporary Laws", they remain in effect until 1914 and trigger a mass migration of Jews, mostly to the United States, some to Palestine.

Policy: Force one third of Jews to flee, one third to convert, kill one third.


Konstantin Petrovich Pobedonostsev
Advisor to Czar Alexander III, despised democracy and liberalization of society. He recommended forcing one-third of the Jews to emigrate, one-third to accept baptism, and one-third to starve. (This policy was revived by the Nazi puppet government of "independent" Croatia as a final solution to their Serb problem.)
 
GERMAN EMPIRE:

Einstein age 14, with sister Maja
Through two marriages and many affairs, she remained the closest person in his life.

Young Einstein embraces, then rejects organized religion

At age nine Albert moves from elementary Volksshule to the local Luitpold Gymnasium, a Catholic school. Bavarian law requires religious instruction, so Albert is tutored at home in Judaism by a distant relative. Around age 11 he goes through an intense religious phase, composing hymns to God which he belts out to himself on the way to school. To his parents' amusement he urges them to forgo pork, in keeping with Jewish dietary rules (they decline). This phase abruptly ends a year later when he discovers science. (Pais, Abraham, Subtle is the Lord: The Science and the Life of Albert Einstein, Oxford University Press 1982. pg. 37)

 

One Jewish practice that the Einstein family does practice
is that of hosting a poor Jewish student for one meal each week. For five years, starting when Albert is ten the Einsteins are joined each Thursday for dinner by medical student Max Talmud ("Talmey" after emigrating to America). Talmud introduces young Albert to science and philosophy.
Max Talmud (later "Talmey")
A Jewish custom of community support to impoverished students brings the medical student to the Einstein home for dinner every Thursday. He introduces young Albert to science and philosophy.
 
1889

14 years old
With Talmey's encouragement he had read Kant's Critique of Pure reason the year before, at 13.

Munich class picture
Here he learns to detest regimentation, rote learning and mindless drill. Military marching actually frightens him. Einstein's teachers regard him a smart ass who engenders disrespect for authority.

RECALLING ANTI-SEMITISM OF
HIS EARLY SCHOOL YEARS

The teaching staff of the elementary school was liberal and made no denominational distinctions. Among the Gymnasium teachers there were quite a few anti-Semites, one in particular who never let us forget that he was a reserve officer. Anti-Semitism was evident among the children, particularly in the elementary school. Physical assaults and and insults were frequent on the way to school, though for the most part not really malicious. Even so, even in a child of my age, a vivid feeling of not belonging.

1920 draft of letter written by Einstein , age forty, recalling elementary school years. Cited in Banesh Hoffman, article p. 235

1893

Founding of assimilationist "German Citizens of the Jewish Faith". Einstein will rebuff them in favor of a Zionist outlook. link
Dominant view of three competing approaches to Jewish identity: Jewish religion is a "confessional faith" alongside Protestantism and Catholicism.

German Citizens of the Jewish Faith
Three approaches will dominate German Jewish life in Einstein's time. The prevalent assimilationist current is embodied in the organization founded in 1893.
"We are not German Jews," they declare. "We are German citizens of the Jewish faith."
Einstein will rebuff their effort to recruit him. 
link He also distanced himself from the second, leftist revolutionary movement - though he sympathized with leftist causes. He identified himself with the third stream: Zionism.

1894
GERMAN EMPIRE / ITALY / SWITZERLAND

Einstein family moves to Milan, Italy - without Albert
Abandoning his languishing business Hermann hopes to find better prospects for electrotechnical business in Italy. They leave 15-year-old Albert in care of distant relatives.

Einstein joins his family in Italy, then completes high school in Switzerland. He relinquish his German citizenship.
Depressed, Albert secures a physician's excuse and drops out of school within a few months of his family's move. He rejoins his startled parents in Italy.  Still without having completed secondary school, he applies to the Swiss Federal Institute of Technology, but fails the entrance exam (though with high marks in math and physics).

 

He spends the next year in at the district secondary school in Aarau, near Zurich.

Federal Institute of Technology
Einstein's was told to finish high school, then apply again.
RUSSIAN EMPIRE:


Czar Nicholas II
Succeeds his father Alexander III in 1894. He will be last Russian Czar.

 

FRANCE:

The Trial of Alfred Dreyfus

Captain Alfred Dreyfus
Einstein was 16 years old in 1895 when the innocent French captain Alfred Dreyfus was maliciously framed on a charge of treason. The nationwide outburst of anti-Semitism in liberal, democratic France, the very cradle of Jewish emancipation, gave great impetus to Zionism.

This photo of Dreyfus on trial appears in Martin Gilbert, The Jews in the Twentieth Century, picture research by Sarah Jackson and Franziska Payer Crockett, Schoken Books, New York 2001

Anti-Semitic outpouring unleashed by Dreyfus trial
Reporting on the trial for a Viennese newspaper, journalist Theodor Herzl notes the anti-Semitism rampant in the very cradle of Jewish emancipation. He concludes that full acceptance of Jews in Europe is impossible.

Death to the Jews! Death to the traitors!

1896

SWITZERLAND:

High school at Aarau, Switzerland. Einstein seated on left

Einstein completes high school in Switzerland.
During his year in Aarau he lives with the Wintler family. 16-year-old Albert develops a crush on one of the daughters, Marie Winteler. In 1898 his good friend Michele Besso will marry Marie's sister Anna, and in 1911 his sister marries a brother, Paul Wintler.
Also rooming with the Wintlers that year:is Einsteins first cousin, Robert Koch. His wife and daughters will be murdered by the Nazis in 1944.

Enters Swiss Federal Institute of Technology
One week after graduating Aarau he is accepted into and starts four years at ETH, one of 23 students studying math and natural sciences.

Here he will make lifelong friends with fellow students Marcel Grossman and Michele Basso. Heinrich Zangger, a  physician and major presence at the academy also befriends him. Over the years all three will receive letters from Einstein on his increasing commitment to Zionism (as well as on many other topics).

Einstein meets classmate Mileva Maric
Like Einstein, she is studying for a diploma that will qualify her to teach high school math and physics. She is three and a half years older, of Serbian parents and Greek Orthodox faith. After she leaves for study in Heidelberg he begins writing her passionate letters. They will not be discovered until 1973 when his son Hans Albert dies.

The future first Mrs. Einstein
Mileva (in 1899 photo)

 

AUSTRO-HUNGARIAN EMPIRE:

"Far-sighted" Theodor Herzl
Einstein was 17 years old when the man he would later call an "unforgettable" visionary put forth his plan for Jewish political revival, though Einstein wasn't drawn to Zionism until 15 years years later.
Theodore Herzl publishes Der Judenstaat (The Jewish State):

The idea which I have developed in this book is a very old one: it is the restoration of the Jewish State...

We shall live at last as free men on our own soil, and die peacefully in our own homes....

whatever we attempt there to accomplish for our own welfare, will react powerfully and beneficially for the good of humanity.

"[F]ar-sighted men, among whom the unforgettable Herzl stood out above the rest"- Einstein on the First Zionist Congress

 


First Zionist Congress
There is no record of 18 year old  Einstein taking interest in the first Zionist Congress in the summer of 1897. 32 years later he addressed the 16th Zionist Congress, also in Switzerland. Above, Herzl speaks from the podium.

Sunday, August 29

Herzl at First Zionist Congress, Basel Switzerland
About 200 delegates from 17 countries met in the concert hall of the Basel Municipal Casino to launch the Zionist program. Some twenty years later Einstein recalled the Zionist Movement's founders as "far-sighted men, among whom the unforgettable Herzl stood out above the rest".

The aim of Zionism is to create for the Jewish People a home in Palestine secured by law.

Resolution of first Zionist Congress

A Jerusalem university is proposed by Zionist delegate Professor Hermann Schapira of Heidelberg.
Realization of this project will become Einstein's primary Zionist focus.

THE OBJECT OF THEIR DESIRE:
PALESTINE: A BACKWATER PROVINCE IN THE CRUMBLING TURKISH EMPIRE


The Ottoman Empire - Palestine district
Lixxxxxxx.

The Ottoman Empire in Decline

Abdul-Hamid II fumes
The Austrian Emperor and the Bulgarian king tear at his empire in this contemporary cartoon from a French magazine.
"Men with a past but without a future" -
Einstein's assessment of the pre-Zionist Jews of Palestine

Surviving mostly on halukah - charitable donations from Jewish communities abroad, there were two distinct Jewish subcommunities in Palestine: Sephardic Jews (from Asia and north Africa) and Ashkenazim (from Hungary, Russia, Rumania and Western Europe). They had few dealings with one another. In the Ottoman Empire they had legal status of dhimmi - "protected" minorities who submitted to Islamic authority and certain formalized humiliations.

Right: Traditional burial spot of Abraham and Sarah in Hebron. Dhimmi Jews were permitted to ascend only as far as the seventh step.

Jews paid a tax to pray at the Western Wall and to the Muslim villagers of Silwan to "protect" Jewish graves on the Mt. of Olives. ( Thomas Idinopulis, Jerusalem Blessed, Jerusalem Cursed: Jews, Christians and Muslims in the Holy City from David's Time to Our Own Chicago, 1991)

At that time there was only a narrow lane in front of the Wall, filthy with donkey droppings and garbage. Jews were permitted no tables or chairs, no coverings from the sun or the traditional divider between men's and women's prayer sections. This status led to one of the most significant events in Zionist development, and Einstein's involvement.

Herodian structure honored as traditional burial spot of Abraham.
Islamic authorities permitted Jews to ascend only to the seventh step.
 
Western "Wailing" Wall
Only a narrow lane in the 1800s, Jews were permitted no improvements.


1890s Jews in Jerusalem ,
Most Jews lived in the cities holy in Jewish tradition: Jerusalem (where they were the majority), Hebron, Safed, Tiberius and
By the end of the century a few brave souls ventured out of the established communities to found agricultural settlements: Jerusalemites established Petah Tikvah (Portal of Hope - in photo) A contingent from Safed founded Rosh Pina (Cornerstone).
1st Aliya 1882-1903

The first of many immigration waves of young, secular Jewish immigrants make their way to Palestine. The oppressive conditions in Russia lead to mass Jewish migration to America, numbers of young Jews being attracted to revolutionary activity, and the taking root of the Zionist movement.

The Zionist immigrants from Russia settled mainly along the coastal plain, founding the community of Rishon le 'Zion (First to Zion) on an uninhabited strip of sandy land southeast of Jaffa. The coastal plain, were was sparsely settled, as most of the population was concentrated in villages in the interior highlands - the modern "West Bank" - the Judea and Samaria of biblical times. Ottoman land reforms had recently encouraged Palestinian Arab notables to acquire large tracts of uncultivated land and to introduce cash crops for export.

The struggling pioneers found a supporter in philanthropist Baron de Rothschild who established a vineyard in their settlement. (Their vintage won the gold medal at Paris Exhibition of 1900 (Ahron Bregman A History of Israel Palgrave Essential Histories 2003)

 
First Aliya to Palestine
The first aliya (wave of Zionist immigrants) bought land along the sparsely inhabited coastal plain. Most of the Arab population then lived in the inland hill country, then called by the biblical names Samaria and Judea - the "West Bank" of modern usage.
photo: Family in Yesud haMa'aleh in the upper Galilee
 

1898

OTTOMAN EMPIRE:

German Kaiser Whilhelm visits Istanbul with side trip to Palestine
The trip strengthens the fast-developing ties between the Ottoman Empire and Germany. Germans become chief providers of weapons and training to the Ottoman army.


1898 Herzl welcomes the German Kaiser Wilhelm to a Zionist agricultural settlement during the German king's visit.
Herzl was convinced Zionism could succeed only if it were allied with a major Western power.


1898 Kaiser Wilhelm at Dome of Rock
1899

EUROPE:

Vast migration of Jews from oppressive Russian Empire
They flee to Central Europe, America, and Palestine

1899 Unflattering postcard depicts Jews driven out of Russia making their way to Germany

 

ALBERT EINSTEIN'S ZIONISM CONTINUES...


Before Zionism
1879-1899
1910-1919
1920-1929
1940-1949